Deborah Vance doesn’t count. The one woman to actually headline the Garden as a stand-up is Amy Schumer, who sold it out a decade ago at the peak of a feminist comedy wave that made her a star. Barone’s new Netflix hour is her bid to bring that moment back, built around jokes about the executives she says she slept with to get it.
At Peacock Theater’s press room on September 14, 2025, Jean Smart and Hannah Einbinder hold their Emmy trophies — Lead and Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series, respectively — after “Hacks” swept both categories at the 77th Primetime Emmy Awards in Los Angeles. Photo by Amy Sussman / Getty Images.
Only a quarter of Netflix’s stand-up specials this year came from women, even as Nikki Glaser, Leanne Morgan and Wanda Sykes fill rooms and the streamer leans into the manosphere with hours from Tony Hinchcliffe and Andrew Schulz.
At the Paramount Theatre in Los Angeles, actress Mary Beth Barone attends HBO’s “I Love LA” premiere on October 28, 2025. Photo by Chris Delmas / AFP via Getty Images.
Barone, 35, made her name on spiky, topical jokes about the obstacle course women face in comedy. In her debut, “Thought Provoking,” she summed it up: “Being a woman in comedy is so much fun, because the goal is to become so successful that you become the most hated person on the entire planet.”
Mary Beth Barone laughs alongside Benito Skinner and Alyssa Hardy during a panel at the 2026 Teen Vogue Fest, held at Duggal Greenhouse in Brooklyn on July 25, 2026. Photo by Bryan Bedder / Getty Images.
Her follow-up, “Galaxy Brain,” opens with her staring into a backstage mirror, the word “Whore” scrawled across her reflection in lipstick. She jokes that women rarely get Netflix specials, then deadpans, “I had to have sex with so many executives over there.”
Maddie Phillips poses on the yellow carpet at the Los Angeles premiere of Prime Video’s ‘Overcompensating’ in Hollywood on May 14, 2025. Photo by MEGA.
She grew up in a Republican home and now calls herself a Democratic Socialist. In 2025 she DMed then-mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani to book him at the Bell House in Brooklyn, and asked him on stage, “Politicians are liars, so how can we trust that these things are achievable?”
At the Paramount Theatre in Los Angeles, Mary Beth Barone arrives for the HBO Original “I Love LA” premiere on October 28, 2025. Photo by Monica Schipper / Getty Images.
Schumer broke through in 2016, months before Ali Wong’s “Baby Cobra” and a year before Hannah Gadsby’s “Nanette” — the stretch between the near-election of a female president and #MeToo that now reads as the commercial high point for marquee feminist stand-up.
Twelve comics have headlined Madison Square Garden in the last three years. This summer Shane Gillis told jokes to almost 74,000 people in Philadelphia, a record for a stand-up show. Barone says she’s writing a new hour about the backlash to #MeToo — whether she’s big enough for those rooms is still an open question.
Stay in the loop with Thought Catalog — follow us on Facebook or visit our website.
Books connect our company’s digital roots with our love of traditional book publishing. Our books are designed as beloved art pieces. We publish work we love.
